Cin Cin de Bortolotti
The Craftsman American Tavern is a premier dining destination in Eagle River that blends the rustic charm of the Northwoods with a modern, sophisticated twist on American tavern fare. Known for its commitment to "craft" quality, the restaurant emphasizes fresh ingredients, creative presentations, and a high level of culinary execution that sets it apart as a refined yet approachable spot for both locals and visitors.
Atmosphere and Experience: The vibe is described as "rustic-chic" or "upscale casual." The interior features beautiful wood accents and a warm, inviting fireplace, creating an environment that is equally suitable for a romantic dinner, a business lunch, or a high-end family gathering. It offers a more polished dining experience than a typical pub, with a professional waitstaff noted for their knowledge of the menu and attentive service.
Detailed Culinary Offerings:
Gourmet Burgers and Sandwiches: This tavern is famous for its elevated take on handhelds. Their burgers are made with premium beef blends and topped with unique ingredients like bourbon-glazed onions, specialty aiolis, and artisanal cheeses. Their "Craftsman Club" and "Hot Honey Chicken" sandwiches are also frequent favorites.
Creative Small Plates: The appetizer menu is a highlight, featuring items like "Duck Wontons" with a sweet chili dipping sauce, giant Bavarian pretzels with house-made beer cheese, and crispy Brussels sprouts tossed in balsamic glaze and bacon.
Signature Entrees: For dinner, the restaurant offers sophisticated plates such as Cedar Plank Salmon, perfectly seared Ribeye steaks, and "Craft Mac & Cheese" which can be customized with various proteins and gourmet toppings.
Fresh Salads and Bowls: They offer several vibrant, meal-sized salads and "Power Bowls" featuring fresh greens, ancient grains, and house-made vinaigrettes, providing excellent options for those seeking lighter but flavorful fare.
Extensive Beverage Program: As a "tavern," they take their drinks seriously. The bar features a wide selection of Wisconsin craft beers on tap, an impressive wine list, and a menu of signature cocktails and "Old Fashioneds" that reflect the local culture with a modern touch.
Key Features:
Outdoor Seating: During the warmer months, the restaurant offers a beautiful outdoor patio area, perfect for enjoying the Northwoods weather.
Dietary Accommodations: The menu is clearly marked with several gluten-free and vegetarian-friendly options, making it an inclusive choice for diverse groups.
Events and Groups: With its spacious and atmospheric layout, it is a top choice for hosting small celebrations or rehearsal dinners in the Eagle River area.